Best Anti Barking Devices: The Complete 2017 Guide

Google+ Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr +

Disclaimer: Please note, we do not publish sponsored posts. However, our posts do contain affiliate links, where we may be compensated for any purchases you make. This does not affect the price you pay. Thanks for supporting our site! 🙂


Barking is natural doggy behaviour — it’s how they communicate — but sometimes it can can get out of hand.

Thankfully, the rise of the anti bark device means that there are plenty of helpful products on the market that can help you manage your pup’s yapping.

stop dog barking device

Let’s find out more…


What is an Anti Bark Device?

An anti barking device is designed to teach your dog that negative things happen every time that they bark, which should result in the dog eventually learning to hold back their barks in order to avoid the negative response.

They used to be used solely to train hunting dogs, but it quickly became clear that they could be a useful tool in training domestic pups too.

Anti bark technology has developed dramatically in recent years, and there are now a wide selection of anti barking devices available to choose from. Here’s a quick guide to the three main types on the market:

Different Types of Stop Barking Device

Sound Emitter

These are either remote devices or collars that work to discourage barking using the power of sound. Sensors will detect when your dog starts barking and will transmit an ultrasonic sound, so high pitched that its only audible to dogs.

The triggered sound will surprise your dog and is unpleasant enough to stop them barking.

If your dog continues to yap, the sound will likely increase to a determined point (always within safe limits) until your dog stops.

Anti Bark Collar

This is very much like the sound emitter, but replaces the high pitched sound with a small jolt of electric shock via the collar. This will surprise your pup and stop the barking.

Modern shock collars are much more humane than in the past, and are always restricted to safe levels of shock, but care should be taken as misuse of an anti bark collar may cause dogs to become aggressive or fearful.

anti barking device

Sprays

It turn out that dogs aren’t too fond of the powerful odor of citronella.

A certain configuration of anti bark device will spray of jet of citronella infused water into your dog’s face each time they bark, again shocking them into submission.

Water spraying collars are also available, which may be slightly less unpleasant for your dog yet still effective.

Are Anti Bark Devices Safe?

There’s plenty of discussion in the dog owning community as to whether the use of an anti bark collar is safe and humane.

As long as you buy high quality, tested and well reviewed products, it ultimately comes down to how you use them.

First things first, you should never attempt to stop your dog barking altogether. As we mentioned earlier, barking is a natural canine behavior and is a way for your dog to communicate, showing you when they’re excited and fearful.

So, an anti bark device should only be used if you consider your pup to be indulging in excessive barking. That is, when they bark for long periods of time for seemingly no reason — not just because there’s someone at the door or if they’re excited to see you.

When you use an anti barking device, make sure to use it sparingly — and certainly not all day every day. It should be deployed as a training tool that teaches your dog an important behavior rather than a permanent fixture around their neck.

The device with the most potential for harm is the shock collars so use these only with careful consideration and even with professional advice before you resort to them.

Always follow the instructions, start gently and use sparingly when it comes to successful use of an anti bark device.


Alternatives to an Anti Barking Device

If you’re not keen on the punishment style of training with an anti bark collar, you could consider a few gentler alternatives first.

Firstly, figure out the cause of your dog’s excessive barking. Is it out of boredom? Are they being territorial? Have they not had proper obedience training?

Many dogs indulge in excessive barking because they have an overabundance of energy. If you suspect that might be your dog’s problem (often its accompanied by other manic behavior like destructive chewing, digging and jumping), you need to commit extra time to exercising them and expending their energy. We’re talking long, daily walks and regular training.

If you suspect that your dog is being territorial, you may need to put in the effort to socialize them better with other people and dogs. Take opportunities to take them to a dog park, meet other people and have other people come to your home. This way, you can train your dog in the proper behavior when people come to visit.

stop barking device

When your dog’s excessive barking is down to the fact that they just bark at anything and everything because they don’t know any better, it’s a good idea to get them started on a regular course of obedience training. You can read our training tips here.

The idea here is to stop reinforcing your dog’s bad behavior. When they start barking for no reason, ignore them and pay them no attention. After a certain period of time, they’ll learn that their barking gets them no attention from you, their owner, and they’ll learn to stop doing it.

When they start being calm and remaining silent in the face of outside stimuli, you can treat them and reward them for their good behavior. This way they know that there are rewards available if they refrain from barking.

Obedience training isn’t an immediate relief from excessive barking like a stop barking device is, but with regular short and sweet sessions, it’s a great way to change your dog’s behavior for the better in the long term.

This video is a great introduction on how to naturally stop your dog’s excessive barking:

 Why Won’t My Dog Stop Barking?

Before you invest in the best anti bark collar, it’s worth taking a moment to actually consider why your dog is engaging in excessive barking and, indeed, if their barking can be considered excessive at all.

Firstly, all dogs bark.

Well, except for those huskies that love to howl.

You’re never going to completely stop your dog barking and you shouldn’t try to either. It’s a natural expression for canines and is one of the ways they communicate with you and other dogs.

And just like how human communication can mean something different every time we open our mouths to speak, it’s the same for dogs. Different barks can suggest your dog is experiencing different emotions. Here’s a great dog bark translation guide.

Acceptable barking includes the following:

  • A bark when the doorbell goes
  • When they’re excited
  • When they’re scared
  • When they’re trying to tell you something — like there’s an intruder in the house

This barking can quickly turn into something excessive, however.

For instance, when they constantly bark at other people and dogs on their ‘territory’, when they get too excited and can’t stop barking, when they can’t stop barking at the door.

And that’s when you turn to anti-bark training and a stop barking device.

Benefits of an Anti Barking Device

While some owners may prefer to go without an anti bark collar, they do have some great, immediate benefits.

If they’re used responsibly, they can be one of the quickest and most effective ways to get your dog to stop their excessive barking.

Here are some of the benefits:

  • A harmless way to teach your dog to rein in their barking
  • Safe and easy for humans to use
  • Some devices can be used remotely — great if you’re out in the park or not at your dog’s side
  • Can help stop other destructive behaviors, like chewing and digging

The best anti bark device will also be an effective last resort if you’ve tried all the training and exercises available to you but your dog still won’t stop barking.

The Bark Collar Store

We’re going to review the best anti bark devices on Amazon in a moment, but you may also like to explore the online Bark Collar Store, which specializes in — exactly what it sounds like — bark control devices for dogs.

They sell shock bark collars, spray collars, ultrasonic units and more.

Their store is huge and has products suitable for small dogs all the way up to the biggest hounds.

Plus free shipping for orders over $50!

If you’re struggling with excessive barking, it’s definitely worth checking out their store and advice.

Bark Collar, Bark Control, Stop Barking

The Best Anti Bark Device Reviews

best anti bark device

Before we get down to the nitty gritty detail, let’s take a look at how our top picks for the best anti bark collar compare against each other.

We’ve tried to pull together some low-cost budget options with some of the more premium devices available, so there should be something in here to fit your budget.

Here’s how they compare:

3.5*5*3.5*4.5*5*
Ultrasonic SoundStatic StimulationUltrasonic SoundUltrasonic SoundStatic Stimulation
Best for Owners on a BudgetBest for EveryoneBest for Indoor UseBest for Noisy Dog NeighborsBest for Ease of Use
Also: LED FlashlightAlso: Submersible up to 25 FeetAlso: No RechargingAlso: WeatherproofAlso: Doesn't Need Programming

Hoont™ Electronic Handheld Dog Repellent and Trainer with Flashlight

stop barking device

The Hoont Electronic Dog Repellent hand held training aid emits a powerful (yet harmless) ultrasonic sound, teaching your dog to associate the unpleasant sound with disobeying commands to stop barking.

It’s also effective at deterring other destructive behaviors like chewing on furniture and jumping on guests. You control the handheld remote so can incorporate it as a tool into your training routine. It works remotely up to a whopping 50 feet away.

Some buyers also choose to use it as a dog repellant, which you may find useful if you have a particularly aggressive neighbor’s dog, or if you often find dogs on your lawn.

Pros

  • Harmless (yet annoying) to dogs and safe (and inaudible) for humans
  • Can be used remotely up to 50 feet away
  • Small, portable device that easily fits in your pocket or handbag
  • Has an LED flashlight which also acts as a battery indicator
  • Can also be used to deter other unwanted behaviors
  • Your dog doesn’t need to wear a collar or experience any shocks
  • Also has an ‘audible’ button if you need to alert people around you that you may be attacked by a dog or require assistance

Cons

  • Requires a 9v battery which is not included
  • Some buyers expressed doubts that the ‘audible’ setting was as effective

anti bark collar

SportDOG Brand NoBark 10R Rechargeable Bark Collar

This is a very popular anti bark device by SportDOG, boasting ‘perfect bark technology’. It’s considered one of, if not the, best anti bark collar on the market.

There are plenty of options for you to tailor the collar to your dog’s needs, with 10 levels of static stimulation and 3 different training modes to choose from: temperament learning, progressive correction and user selected.

There’s no separate handheld control with this anti barking device. Instead, the collar has an in-built sensor which detects barking via both sounds and vibration from the vocal cords, meaning it won’t get to work if it simply hears any dog barking.  It’s a smart device with the ability to remember the last static stimulation correction level it used, and an automatic shut-off after 3 minutes.

The user selected mode allows you to choose the correction level of the static stimulation, instead of starting at the lowest level and progressing upwards.

It’s suitable for dogs weighing 8 lbs and over.

Pros

  • 3 different modes of learning
  • 10 different levels of static stimulation
  • Sophisticated bark sensor – no false triggers
  • DryTek waterproof and submersible to 25 feet
  • Automatic 3 minute shut-off for safety
  • Charge lasts 3-6 months per charge
  • Smart correction memory

Cons

  • A little expensive compared to others on this list

anti bark collar

First Alert Bark Genie Handheld Bark Control

best anti bark collar

This handheld anti bark device also uses harmless ultrasonic sound to calm and distract barking dogs. Simply activate the device with a push of the button at a distance of up to 15 feet away to divert correct your dog’s behavior.

The device is made by First Alert, a company with a long heritage of manufacturing household products, and they carefully develop all their pet products with professional trainers and experts in order to hit on the best results.

Pros

  • Only dogs can hear the harmless ultrasound waves
  • Works within a range of up to 15 feet
  • Works on all breeds
  • Battery operated so no recharging required
  • Small and portable with an adjustable wrist strap
  • Comes with a 1 year warranty
  • Flashing LED light tells you when to change the battery

Cons

  • At a maximum of 15 feet, the device range is small
  • Device is fragile and can break easily if dropped

anti bark collar

DOGTEK Sonic Bird House Bark Control

anti barking device

This anti bark device is a little kooky but it’s undoubtedly popular with dog owners.

The cute birdhouse design of the DOGTEK Sonic Birdhouse means that it fits unobtrusively into your garden. It uses high-pitched ultrasonic sound technology which is triggered automatically when within range of a barking dog. It has 3 sensors and 4 different sensitivity levels so you can adjust how bark sensitive the contraption is.

Your dog will begin to associate their bark with this unpleasant noise and will eventually learn to stop barking.

Pros

  • Has an effective range of up to 50 feet (also works on your neighbors’ dogs!)
  • Adjustable sensitivity settings
  • Weatherproof and durable
  • Suitable for outdoor and indoor use
  • Sturdy unit
  • Looks cute!

Cons

  • You’ll have to crank the sensitivity levels up for higher-pitched barking dogs
  • Uses up battery life relatively quickly

anti bark collar

PetSafe Basic Bark Control Collar

anti barking device

For many owners, this is the best anti bark collar on the market: it’s easy to use, safe, and super effective at reducing your pup’s excessive barking.

When your dog barks, the vibration triggers the collar to administer a static correction, beginning at the lowest level and gradually increasing if your dog continues to bark (although always within safe limits and stopping after 50 seconds).

Once barking stops, the collar will reset itself to the lowest level for any later barking. The static correction is only a gentle tingle that indicate a new sensation to your dog, thus distracting them and stopping the barking.

This anti bark collar is suitable for dogs weighing 8 lbs and over.

Pros

  • Lightweight and waterproof up to 5 feet
  • Six levels of static correction
  • Battery indicator signals when it is time to change the battery
  • Can’t be triggered by other dogs barking as it detects vocal cord vibration from your dog’s bark
  • Anti bark collar beeps every time there’s a static correction so you can monitor your pup’s progress
  • Will shut off for 3 minutes if your dog barks over 15 times in 50 seconds
  • Easy to use and doesn’t need programming prior to use

Cons

  • Only suitable for dogs 8lbs and over
  • Doesn’t have any impact on other nuisance behavior, only barking

anti bark collar

Conclusion

If you’re fed up with your dog’s excessive barking and have tried training and exercise to no avail, it’s a great idea to consider the merits of a stop barking device.

Hopefully now you’ll be equipped with all the knowledge you need on the best anti bark device for your dog. Just remember to praise and reward your furry friend during their corrective training!

Our readers love these products



Share.

16 Comments

    • I’ve got the sport dog 10r collar for my Pom who’s about the same weight. Think they’re suitable for dogs 8 pounds and up. Hope this helps you. It’s great.

    • Hi Sally. Both the SportDOG and PetSafe collars will be suitable for your Pomeranian. Amazon also have some specifically made for small dogs. Let us know which one you pick!

  1. Just want to say that I really recommend the SportDog 10R bark collar. I have them for my Staffy and Rottie and they’ve both totally transformed with regular training using it.

  2. Thank you for this. I’ve been going backwards and forwards on whether to get an anti-bark collar for my baby as he’s such a loud barker but was a bit worried that it might be seen as cruel. Good to see other people ar e buying them!!!

    • They definitely are, Leanne! Remember that the power lies with you to ensure that you use an anti bark collar in the most humane and kind way possible.

  3. I have neighbors on both sides of my yard with dogs that sound like a pack of wolves their barking and howling is so loud! I am thinking of buying that one that looks like a bird house as it has a range of 50 feet but I don’t want my neighbors to know that it’s actually to stop their dogs. Do you know if it could actually pass as a bird house? Just so if they look over the fence it just looks like a bird house and not something more sinister lol.

    • Hi Margie,

      The DOGTEK definitely looks like a proper bird house as long as you don’t get too up close to examine it. We think it will be fine if you’re just looking over the fence at it. Obviously, birds won’t use it as a bird house as there’s nowhere to place food but it should be fine if you place it somewhere discrete.

  4. I have 4 Pitbulls, 6,3, 1.5 x 2. I have a petsafe antibark egg and it works great for the older 2 dogs but does nothing for the younger 2. The younger 2 bark at everything and then it sets the older 2 off. I desperately need help. PLEASE HELP!!!!!

    • Hi Alisha,

      That’s interesting — perhaps the younger 2 hear a different frequency that doesn’t affect them as much as the older two.

      Personally, we prefer the DOGTEK bird house for ultrasonic control. It allows you to adjust the sensitivity — you would probably need to put it on high as you have four dogs.

    • Hi James,

      Sorry to hear you’ve had trouble with the sonic — it might be worth sending it back and getting a new one if it’s not working at all. Sounds like a defected product, perhaps!

  5. Anyone tell me the battery life on the
    DOGTEK Sonic Bird House Bark Control I have read many of these devises can drive one broke in battery replacement. I need something that we can place outdoor to stop neighbors hounds from driving the neighborhood and us nuts when it’s nice and the windows can be open. We have been dealing with this problem for almost a year the guy who owns these dogs could care less and curses neighbors who yell at his dogs.

  6. Dannean Altman on

    my dog wears a collar for electric fence so how will a bark collar work with that? Bulky additional collar that freaks the dog out bc it doesn’t know what it’s for? Is the ultrasound a better choice for dogs who wear the electric fence collars?

Leave A Reply